Toronto · 3-4-3
| 1 | Luka Gavran | |
| 25 | Walker Zimmerman | |
| 13 | Benjamín Kuscevic | |
| 12 | Zane Monlouis | ▼ 45' |
| 21 | Jonathan Osorio | |
| 8 | José Cifuentes | ▼ 70' |
| 44 | Raheem Edwards | ▼ 82' |
| 22 | Richie Laryea | |
| 17 | Emilio Aristizábal | ▼ 45' |
| 20 | Dániel SallóiG | |
| 10 | Djordje Mihailovic | ▼ 87' |
| Suplentes |
|---|
| 11 | Derrick Etienne Jr. | ▲ 45' |
| 23 | William Yarbrough | |
| 19 | Kobe Franklin | ▲ 82' |
| 78 | Malik Henry | |
| 76 | Lazar Stefanovic | |
| 14 | Alonso Coello | ▲ 87' |
| 6 | Kosi Thompson | |
| 29 | Deandre Kerr | ▲ 45' |
| 9 | Josh Sargent | ▲ 70' |
Red Bull NY · 4-1-4-1
| 34 | Ethan Horvath | |
| 6 | Robert Voloder | |
| 2 | Justin Che | ▼ 90'+2' |
| 15 | Adri Mehmeti | |
| 56 | Matthew Dos Santos | ▼ 77' |
| 3 | Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty | |
| 10 | Emil Forsberg | |
| 48 | Ronald Donkor | ▼ 77' |
| 37 | Mohammed Sofo | ▼ 66' |
| 11 | Jorge Ruvalcaba | |
| 16 | Julian Hall | |
| Suplentes |
|---|
| 70 | Andy Rojas | |
| 79 | Rafael Mosquera | |
| 20 | Juan González | |
| 13 | Eric Maxim Choupo-MotingG | ▲ 77' |
| 26 | Tim Parker | ▲ 90'+2' |
| 5 | Omar Valencia | ▲ 77' |
| 77 | John McCarthy | |
| 4 | Gustaf Beggren | |
| 66 | Tanner Rosborough | ▲ 66' |
Estadísticas
| Toronto | | Red Bull NY |
| 32,3 | Posesión % | 67,7 |
| 12 | Remates | 17 |
| 6 | Remates al arco | 8 |
| 5 | Córners | 11 |
| 10 | Faltas | 13 |
| 1 | Fuera de juego | 2 |
| 1 | Amarillas | 2 |
| 0 | Rojas | 0 |
| 7 | Atajadas | 5 |
| 287 | Pases | 590 |
| 70 | Pases correctos % | 90 |
G gol · amarilla · roja · ▲ entró · ▼ salió