Columbus · 3-4-3
| 28 | Patrick Schulte | |
| 25 | Sean Zawadzki | |
| 18 | Malte Amundsen | |
| 31 | Steven Moreira | |
| 20 | André Gomes | ▼ 83' |
| 50 | Tarun Karumanchi | |
| 11 | Brooks Lennon | |
| 26 | Laurtaro Giaccone | ▼ 83' |
| 33 | Gonzalo Tapia | ▼ 71' |
| 8 | Santiago Rodríguez | ▼ 75' |
| 10 | Brais Méndez | |
| Suplentes |
|---|
| 7 | Dylan Chambost | ▲ 83' |
| 16 | Taha Habroune | ▲ 75' |
| 19 | Jamal Thiaré | ▲ 83' |
| 14 | Amar Sejdic | |
| 3 | Eric Bailly | |
| 24 | Evan Bush | |
| 1 | Nicholas Hagen | |
| 77 | Josef Martínez | ▲ 71' |
| 12 | Cesar Ruvalcaba | |
Red Bull NY · 4-3-3
| 34 | Ethan Horvath | |
| 14 | Julián Bazán | |
| 26 | Tim Parker | |
| 56 | Matthew Dos Santos | ▼ 66' |
| 12 | Dylan Nealis | |
| 15 | Adri Mehmeti | ▼ 80' |
| 37 | Mohammed Sofo | |
| 48 | Ronald DonkorG | |
| 16 | Julian Hall | ▼ 80' |
| 11 | Jorge Ruvalcaba | ▼ 66' |
| 17 | Cameron Harper | ▼ 90' |
| Suplentes |
|---|
| 8 | David Ruiz | ▲ 80' |
| 60 | Sékou Koné | |
| 92 | Dennis Nelich | ▲ 90' |
| 77 | John McCarthy | |
| 7 | Cade Cowell | ▲ 66' |
| 10 | Emil Forsberg | |
| 13 | Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting | ▲ 80' |
| 59 | Devin Padelford | ▲ 66' |
| 6 | Robert Voloder | |
Estadísticas
| Columbus | | Red Bull NY |
| 58,8 | Posesión % | 41,2 |
| 12 | Remates | 15 |
| 4 | Remates al arco | 5 |
| 7 | Córners | 3 |
| 12 | Faltas | 14 |
| 2 | Fuera de juego | 3 |
| 2 | Amarillas | 2 |
| 0 | Rojas | 0 |
| 4 | Atajadas | 3 |
| 549 | Pases | 395 |
| 90 | Pases correctos % | 80 |
G gol · amarilla · roja · ▲ entró · ▼ salió